Your Holiday Party Needs One Weird Drink
I love a holiday party. I love the excuse to dress up, the abundance of cheese, and the fact that drinking Champagne on a Wednesday suddenly feels perfectly reasonable. But I have one big complaint: Our holiday drinks have gotten a little boring.
Don’t get me wrong. There’s nothing wrong with opening a good bottle of wine, stirring a classic martini, or pouring a glass of bubbles. I’ll happily do and drink any of the above. But if we’re already going all out on decorations, food, and an outfit we’ll probably only wear once, why are we playing it so safe with the drinks? My proposition: Every holiday party needs one weird drink.
I’m not suggesting an elaborate cocktail menu or anything that requires an advanced understanding of molecular mixology. I’m talking about one unexpected, perhaps slightly ridiculous drink that becomes a stand-out part of the evening. Maybe a giant punch bowl. Or a retro Grasshopper. Even a magnum of wine. A “weird drink,” in this case, is something that gives people a reason to gather around, ask questions, and maybe even try something they wouldn’t ordinarily order.
“It is a wonderful idea to have a centerpiece, out-of-the-box, super festive cocktail at a holiday party,” says Charlotte Voisey, executive director of the Tales of the Cocktail Foundation. “It’s the sequin dress of the drinks trolley! One we get to pull out and enjoy on special occasions embracing the lavishness of the holiday time.”
I think she’s onto something. After all, if there’s a time of year to embrace a little excess, it’s the end-of-year holidays after a particularly wild 12 months. Here’s why you need to have a weird drink at your next holiday party.
Drinks Should Be Part of the Entertainment
Somewhere along the way, we’ve gotten very serious about cocktails. And while I appreciate the precision of a beautifully made drink, like a martini calibrated to the exact degree of dilution, I also appreciate a drink that doesn’t take itself quite so seriously.
At Bar di Bello in Los Angeles, co-owner and executive beverage director Kristin Olszewski (who also happens to be the creator of canned and boxed wine brand Nomadica) serves the Negroni di Basso, inspired by the famously oversized Negronis at Bar Basso in Milan. It’s a double Negroni served in an enormous goblet, and when one is delivered to a table, the restaurant rings a bell.
“We often have two or three guests sharing one, which makes it even more fun and communal,” says Olszewski. “We ring a bell in the dining room when we serve it, and our room is really small—just twelve tables—so it makes the whole thing feel like a party.” It’s not that the Negroni needs improving, whether at Bar Basso, Bar di Bello, or elsewhere. It’s that the fun, unusual presentation turns ordering a cocktail into something people experience together.
And that’s exactly what makes this idea work at home, particularly when your guest list includes people who don’t necessarily know one another. A little novelty can help make conversation easier by offering everyone something to talk about. As Los Angeles bartender Linda Douglas puts it, “A fun drink can bring people together in an awkward office party setting or remind people what it felt like to be excited for the season.”
Sam Penton, director of food and beverage at Municipal Grand in Savannah, Georgia, also makes a case for embracing vintage and mismatched glassware. Have a handful of colorful coupe glasses from the 1970s? Put them to use. Not only does it make the presentation more interesting, but there’s something appealing about serving a drink in a glass that comes with its own origin story.
A holiday party is exactly the right setting where we can let drinks be fun for the sake of being fun. Not everything needs to be a master class in technique or a showcase of expensive ingredients.
I’m Ready for the Return of the Punch Bowl
Of all the things that could make a comeback in entertaining, I might be most enthusiastic about the punch bowl.
Andrew Zerrip, bar director at Tokyo Record Bar in New York City, likes how a communal punch bowl gives everyone the same shared experience, rather than a collection of individual cocktail orders. Especially during the holidays, a fun communal cocktail offers a sense of nostalgia, he says, bringing to mind family holiday gatherings with big bowls of eggnog or sherbet punch. Moreover, a punch that all guests can drink gives everyone something in common to talk about or bond over.
But there’s another reason I think punch bowls are overdue for a return: They’re practical. And while practicality might seem at odds with my argument for a weird drink, hear me out. You can make one large-format cocktail before anyone arrives, set it somewhere accessible, and let guests serve themselves. No running back and forth to the kitchen, no making six martinis while everyone else is having fun.
Douglas recommends picking up a vintage punch bowl at a thrift store or estate sale and making a large ice mold with fruit and herbs frozen inside. (Zerrip recommends frozen cranberries to replace ice, where it makes sense.) It’s an easy way to make an inexpensive, relatively simple cocktail feel more considered.
And frankly, there’s something appealing about bringing back the kind of entertaining traditions that existed long before everyone worried about having a perfectly styled bar cart.
Give the Old-School Drinks Another Chance
I’m also in favor of reconsidering some of the drinks we’ve collectively decided are outdated. Take the Grasshopper. It’s creamy, minty, chocolatey, and bright green. It’s not subtle, but why does it need to be? Sean Marino, bar manager at Bangkok Supper Club in New York City, thinks the classic cocktail deserves a holiday comeback, particularly because of its festive flavors and distinctive appearance.
I myself am partial to bringing back the Pink Squirrel, made with heavy cream, crème de cacao, and crème de noyaux (a liqueur made from distilled stone fruit pits), topped with maraschino cherries; other variations garnish with grated nutmeg to underscore the nut theme. It’s pink! It’s fun! And with a name like that, you can’t beat it.
Penton makes the case for Sherry Cobblers, an easy (and low-abv) drink of Sherry, citrus, and sweetener. His suggestion is to create a build-your-own cobbler station with different Sherries, fruits, and glassware, giving guests a chance to experiment with an old-school drink they might not otherwise encounter.
Then there’s mulled white wine, which Douglas would like to see more of during the holidays. Most of us are familiar with mulled red wine, but she suggests using white wine as a base for citrus, ginger, cardamom, bay leaf, or a little elderflower liqueur. It’s familiar enough to appeal to a diverse crowd, but different enough to warrant a conversation.
And if cocktails aren’t your thing, there’s always the option of simply serving something in a much larger bottle than necessary. Olszewski recalls opening magnums of 2019 Château Simone rosé for her husband’s birthday and watching guests become fascinated by the oversized format, even though most weren’t wine professionals. It’s a reminder that the experience of drinking something can be just as memorable as what’s actually in the glass.
Just Don’t Make It More Work Than It’s Worth
There is, however, a limit to how far I’d take the novelty. If your weird drink involves so much preparation that you’re stressed before guests even arrive, you’ve probably missed the point.
“First and foremost, the drink has to taste good,” says Zerrip. His advice is to start with a familiar cocktail and build on it with seasonal ingredients, whether that’s a spice-infused spirit, a flavored syrup, or an unexpected garnish. Frozen fruit can replace ice, candy canes can double as stir sticks, and interesting glassware can make even a simple cocktail feel special.
Marino also suggests a clarified cocktail as another option for hosts who want to show off their bartending skills while still serving something balanced and easy to pour once guests arrive. It requires more advance preparation, but eliminates the need to make drinks individually throughout the night. Voisey recommends letting the presentation do some of the work, too. Edible glitter, holiday-themed garnishes, and even a station where guests can finish their own cocktails create an interactive element without requiring the host to learn complicated techniques.
Ultimately, the best weird drink is one that feels a little excessive but is actually easy to execute. That’s why I’m particularly partial to large-format cocktails, vintage glassware, and drinks that lean into nostalgia rather than technical difficulty. The point isn’t to impress everyone with your bartending skills. It’s to give people something to enjoy together, whether that’s a drink they’ve never tried, a presentation they weren’t expecting, or a tradition they’d forgotten about.
And look, I’m not suggesting you abandon the wine and Champagne. There’s plenty of room for both. But when you think back on the best parties you’ve attended, chances are you remember the unexpected moments more than what was actually on the menu. Your holiday drinks deserve a few of those moments, too.
The post Your Holiday Party Needs One Weird Drink appeared first on Wine Enthusiast.